Incident Overview

Date: Friday 11 May 1990
Aircraft Type: Cessna 500 Citation I
Owner/operator: Air North Queensland
Registration Number: VH-ANQ
Location: 15 km S of Mareeba, QLD – ÿ Australia
Phase of Flight: En route
Status: Destroyed, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 11 / Occupants: 11
Component Affected: The Cessna 500 VH-ANQ aircraft itself. The incident highlights the potential risks associated with aircraft navigation, communication, and the impact of terrain on flight operations.The Cessna 500 VH-ANQ aircraft itself. The incident highlights the potential risks associated with aircraft navigation, communication, and the impact of terrain on flight operations.
Investigating Agency: BASIBASI
Category: Accident
On 12 May 1990, Cessna 500 VH-ANQ experienced a sudden and unexpected descent of approximately 6,400 feet during a charter flight from Proserpine to Mareeba. The aircraft was initially flying at FL330, tracked via overhead Townsville, and directed to Mareeba with a flight time interval of 68 minutes. The pilot initiated a descent to FL170, then to FL120, and subsequently instructed to descend to FL10,000 feet. The pilot reported the aircraft was approaching over Mareeba and visual, and then, after a brief delay, instructed to circle over Mareeba. The pilot’s final transmission was unanswered, leading to the wreckage being discovered 15 kilometers south of Mareeba Airport. The wreckage was located on Mt Emerald, suggesting a significant impact with the terrain.On 12 May 1990, Cessna 500 VH-ANQ experienced a sudden and unexpected descent of approximately 6,400 feet during a charter flight from Proserpine to Mareeba. The aircraft was initially flying at FL330, tracked via overhead Townsville, and directed to Mareeba with a flight time interval of 68 minutes. The pilot initiated a descent to FL170, then to FL120, and subsequently instructed to descend to FL10,000 feet. The pilot reported the aircraft was approaching over Mareeba and visual, and then, after a brief delay, instructed to circle over Mareeba. The pilot’s final transmission was unanswered, leading to the wreckage being discovered 15 kilometers south of Mareeba Airport. The wreckage was located on Mt Emerald, suggesting a significant impact with the terrain.

Description

Cessna 500 VH-ANQ was operating the Proserpine to Mareeba leg of a charter flight The aircraft departed Proserpine at 16:35 hours. The charter flight had been organised to transport members of five local government authorities from the Cairns/Atherton Tablelands area to a Local Government Association Conference at Airlie Beach, Queensland. The flight plan indicated that the flight would follow Instrument Flight Rules (IFR) with a planned cruising altitude of FL330. The aircraft was planned to track via overhead Townsville then direct to Mareeba with a flight time interval of 68 minutes. The flight apparently continued normally and at 17:26 the aircraft was cleared to descend to FL170 and instructed to call Cairns Approach. On first contact with Cairns Approach, the pilot advised that the aircraft was tracking for Mareeba via the 163 radial at 41 miles (76 kilometres) DME from Biboohra. (There are no radio navigational aids at Mareeba, the nearest aids for tracking and instrument approach purposes are at Biboohra, about 16 kilometres north of Mareeba). The aircraft was advised to maintain FL170 but a short time later was cleared to descend to FL120. The pilot stated that he would not be closing down the engines at Mareeba and that his estimated departure time was 17:50. At 17:35 hours VH-ANQ was cleared to descend to 10,000 feet and one minute later the pilot advised that the aircraft was “approaching over Mareeba and visual”. Cairns Approach advised VH-ANQ that there would be a short delay at 10,000 feet and following a request from the pilot gave approval for the aircraft to circle over Mareeba. At 17:40 hours, Cairns Approach instructed the aircraft to descend to 7,000 feet. This transmission, and other subsequent transmissions to the aircraft, went unanswered. The wreckage of VH-ANQ was ultimately located on the eastern slopes of Mt Emerald, 15 kilometres south of Mareeba Airport, by searching helicopters at 0240 hours on 12 May 1990. The aircraft initially impacted the mountainside with the left wingtip, while travelling on a track of about 340 degrees Magnetic. At the time it was in a wings level attitude at an angle of descent of eight degrees. It then struck the ground just below the apex of a ridge and the wreckage spread in a fan shape, at an angle of 30 degrees, along a centreline track of 350 degrees Magnetic. RELEVANT EVENTS AND FACTORS This accident was unusual in that the last report by the pilot indicated that the aircraft was at 10,000 feet and on a track that was 55 kilometres to the east of the accident site. There was no substantiated, and very little circumstantial evidence to suggest what caused the aircraft to descend 6,400 feet and to be displaced a considerable distance to the west of track. As a result the causal factors associated with this accident remain undetermined.

Primary Cause

The abrupt and unexpected descent, coupled with the pilot’s instructions to descend to a lower altitude, likely resulted from a combination of factors, potentially including a sudden change in wind conditions, a malfunction in the aircraft’s navigation system, or a miscalculation of the flight path. The pilot’s communication failure and the lack of immediate response to the situation suggest a potential issue with communication or a critical system failure.The abrupt and unexpected descent, coupled with the pilot’s instructions to descend to a lower altitude, likely resulted from a combination of factors, potentially including a sudden change in wind conditions, a malfunction in the aircraft’s navigation system, or a miscalculation of the flight path. The pilot’s communication failure and the lack of immediate response to the situation suggest a potential issue with communication or a critical system failure.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *