Incident Overview

Date: Monday 3 January 2011
Aircraft Type: Boeing 737-823 (WL)
Owner/operator: American Airlines
Registration Number: N831NN
Location: Los Angeles International Airport, CA (LAX) – ÿ United States of America
Phase of Flight: Take off
Status: Substantial, repaired
Casualties: Fatalities: 0 / Occupants: 165
Component Affected: Boeing 737-800 Aircraft ? Specifically, the tail skid, the automatic V1 callout system, and the flight management computer (FMC) data entry.Boeing 737-800 Aircraft ? Specifically, the tail skid, the automatic V1 callout system, and the flight management computer (FMC) data entry.
Investigating Agency: NTSBNTSB
Category: Accident
An American Airlines Boeing 737-800 experienced a tailstrike during takeoff from Runway 7L at Los Angeles International Airport, California, on May 1, 2024. No injuries occurred. The flight landed unprompted at Toronto-Lester Pearson International Airport, Canada, resulting in damage to the tail skid. The captain initiated a rotation to compensate for airspeed discrepancies, which was subsequently halted due to the automatic V1 callout. The initial rotation was executed at a speed of approximately 10 degrees, resulting in a V1 of 153 knots. The first officer manually entered takeoff data, which was subsequently updated with information from preflight paperwork. The initial data V speeds were incorrect, leading to a manually entered takeoff speed of 123 knots for V1, 153 knots for Vr, and 158 knots for V2. The rotation was triggered by the Captain’s assumption of a potentially incorrect Vr value, potentially due to a keystroke error.An American Airlines Boeing 737-800 experienced a tailstrike during takeoff from Runway 7L at Los Angeles International Airport, California, on May 1, 2024. No injuries occurred. The flight landed unprompted at Toronto-Lester Pearson International Airport, Canada, resulting in damage to the tail skid. The captain initiated a rotation to compensate for airspeed discrepancies, which was subsequently halted due to the automatic V1 callout. The initial rotation was executed at a speed of approximately 10 degrees, resulting in a V1 of 153 knots. The first officer manually entered takeoff data, which was subsequently updated with information from preflight paperwork. The initial data V speeds were incorrect, leading to a manually entered takeoff speed of 123 knots for V1, 153 knots for Vr, and 158 knots for V2. The rotation was triggered by the Captain’s assumption of a potentially incorrect Vr value, potentially due to a keystroke error.

Description

American Airlines flight 1586, a Boeing 737-800, experienced a tailstrike upon takeoff from runway 7L at Los Angeles International Airport, California, USA. No injuries occurred during the event. The flight landed uneventfully at Toronto-Lester Pearson International Airport, Canada, where damage to the tail skid was discovered. Further damage to the aft pressure bulkhead was later discovered, and this damage was determined to be substantial. According to the captain, normal procedures were followed during preflight and taxi, including verification of the takeoff bug speeds. During the takeoff roll, the automatic, aircraft-generated V1 callout occurred and he began to rotate the airplane. The first officer did not call for rotation at that time. The captain applied nose up pitch command until he realized the indicated airspeed was too low. He said he then eased the nose of the airplane back down to the runway and re-rotated at the normal rotation speed, achieving approximately 10 degrees nose up at about 155 to 160 knots. The FO said he noticed that the automatic voice callout occurred about 20 knots early and observed the captain rotate for takeoff, but he said nothing to the captain for fear of causing confusion. The rest of the climbout, cruise, descent, and landing at Toronto was uneventful. According to the first officer, during preflight preparations, due to a last minute runway change, the takeoff data V speeds did not automatically upload into the flight management computer (FMC), so he manually entered the speeds using information on the preflight paperwork. Flight planning data indicated that the airplane takeoff weight was 161,037 pounds with a center of gravity at 22.5% mean aerodynamic chord, which under the conditions at the time of the accident should have resulted in a flaps 1 takeoff with V1 (takeoff decision speed) of 153 knots, a Vr (rotation speed) also of 153 knots, and V2 (scheduled takeoff speed) of 158 knots. The recorded data indicates the manually entered V speeds in the FMC were V1 123 knots, Vr 153 knots and V2 158 knots. Probable cause: The early rotation of the airplane to an angle at which the fuselage contacted the runway. Contributing to early rotation was the Captain’s reaction to the erroneous V1 automated callout, likely assuming that the airplane was at or close to the correct Vr at the same time. The erroneous automated callout was likely due to a keystroke entry error by the FO when manually entering takeoff data for a newly assigned departure runway.

Primary Cause

Incorrect takeoff data entry and automated V1 callout, likely stemming from a manual override of takeoff data entry by the First Officer.Incorrect takeoff data entry and automated V1 callout, likely stemming from a manual override of takeoff data entry by the First Officer.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *