Incident Overview

Date: Sunday 6 November 2022
Aircraft Type: ATR 42-500 ?
Owner/operator: Precision Air
Registration Number: 5H-PWF
Location: off Bukoba Airport (BKZ) – ÿ Tanzania
Phase of Flight: Approach
Status: Substantial, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 19 / Occupants: 43
Component Affected: Aircraft – Specifically, the final approach phase and the aircraft’s descent rate at low altitude.Aircraft – Specifically, the final approach phase and the aircraft’s descent rate at low altitude.
Investigating Agency: AAIB TanzaniaAAIB Tanzania
Category: Accident
On October 26, 2023, an ATR 42-500 aircraft, piloted by a pilot and two crew members, experienced a catastrophic accident while attempting a final approach to Bukoba Airport (BKZ) in Tanzania. The aircraft crashed into Lake Victoria, resulting in the loss of seventeen lives. Initial reports indicate the aircraft circled twice in the area and the crew advised a diversion to Mwanza. However, the pilot initiated a final approach to runway 31, and the aircraft impacted the lake surface, causing significant damage and resulting in the loss of all passengers and crew. The sudden change in weather, characterized by torrential rain, thunderstorms, and strong winds, significantly impacted visibility and flight stability.On October 26, 2023, an ATR 42-500 aircraft, piloted by a pilot and two crew members, experienced a catastrophic accident while attempting a final approach to Bukoba Airport (BKZ) in Tanzania. The aircraft crashed into Lake Victoria, resulting in the loss of seventeen lives. Initial reports indicate the aircraft circled twice in the area and the crew advised a diversion to Mwanza. However, the pilot initiated a final approach to runway 31, and the aircraft impacted the lake surface, causing significant damage and resulting in the loss of all passengers and crew. The sudden change in weather, characterized by torrential rain, thunderstorms, and strong winds, significantly impacted visibility and flight stability.

Description

Precision Air flight 494, an ATR 42-500, came down in Lake Victoria while on final approach to Bukoba Airport (BKZ), Tanzania. The pilot, copilot and seventeen passengers died in the accident. The aircraft took off from Dar es Salaam at 06:10 hours Local Time and the estimated time of arrival al Bukoba was 08:25. The enroute weather was reported to be fine and the flight to Bukoba was uneventful. The weather at Bukoba was good up to 08:20 when it abruptly changed and started raining with thunderstorms and strong winds. The reported visibility reduced from 10 km to 2 km. The flight reached Bukoba at 08:25 to find that the weather had changed several minutes earlier. There were thunderstorms, Cumulonimbus (CBs) clouds and strong winds. According to eye witnesses the aircraft circled twice in the Bukoba area and the crew advised the passengers that the flight may have to divert to Mwanza if the weather at Bukoba did not improve. However, on the third attempt, the runway became visible and the pilot initiated the approach to runway 31. On final approach the aircraft impacted the water of Lake Victoria. The main landing gear separated and the cabin floor was dislodged by the impact, allowing water to enter the cabin at high pressure as the aircraft decelerated before coming to a stop. Canoes and fishermen arrived after about 5 minutes and they transferred the survivors to their boats. Two crew members and 22 passengers were rescued. Bukoba has a single runway (13/31), 1385 m long. Distance between the shore and the runway 31 threshold is 130 meters. Causal factor The accident was caused by an unstabilized final approach to runway 31 of Bukoba airport conducted in poor weather conditions which did not allow clear sight of the terrain. This led the aircraft to strike the water on the lake surface. Contributory factors The major contributory factors were: i. The decision of the Pilot in Command to proceed with the final approach without the required weather minima in order to reach the runway instead of diverting to Mwanza; ii. The gusting crosswind which prevailed at the time of final approach; iii. The heavy rain and turbulence at that material time iv. The absence of air traffic services at Bukoba Airport v. High rate of descent at low altitude vi. No immediate response to the EGPWS warnings vii. High work load to the crew at the critical phase of final approach.

Source of Information

https://twitter.com/TanzaniaInsight/status/1589167432395915265, https://twitter.com/PrecisionAirTz/status/1589250831160778752, https://tbc.go.tz/kitaifa/26-waokolewa-ajali-ya-ndege-ziwa-victoria/, https://www.tcaa.go.tz/pdf_viewer.php?m=Announcements&t=PUBLIC%20NOTICE&f=files/news/doc_20221106161136_PW%20494%20Landing%20Accident.pdfhttps://twitter.com/TanzaniaInsight/status/1589167432395915265, https://twitter.com/PrecisionAirTz/status/1589250831160778752, https://tbc.go.tz/kitaifa/26-waokolewa-ajali-ya-ndege-ziwa-victoria/, https://www.tcaa.go.tz/pdf_viewer.php?m=Announcements&t=PUBLIC%20NOTICE&f=files/news/doc_20221106161136_PW%20494%20Landing%20Accident.pdf

Primary Cause

Unstabilized final approach to runway 31 due to poor weather conditions, leading to a lack of sufficient visibility and a failure to adhere to required weather minima.Unstabilized final approach to runway 31 due to poor weather conditions, leading to a lack of sufficient visibility and a failure to adhere to required weather minima.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *