Incident Overview

Date: Wednesday 13 April 2011
Aircraft Type: Airbus A330-203
Owner/operator: Air France
Registration Number: F-GZCB
Location: Caracas-Sim¢n Bol¡var International Airport (CCS) – ÿ Venezuela
Phase of Flight: Landing
Status: Substantial, repaired
Casualties: Fatalities: 0 / Occupants: 215
Component Affected: The A330-203 aircraft, specifically the landing gear and fuselage structure. The primary damage is evident in the right-hand main landing gear and fuselage structure, with a significant impact on the landing gear’s fixed piston component.The A330-203 aircraft, specifically the landing gear and fuselage structure. The primary damage is evident in the right-hand main landing gear and fuselage structure, with a significant impact on the landing gear’s fixed piston component.
Investigating Agency: BEABEA
Category: Accident
An Airbus A330-203 experienced a severe hard landing at Caracas-Sim¢n Bol¡var International Airport (CCS) on Venezuela, resulting in significant damage to the aircraft. The flight, originating from Paris-Charles de Gaulle Airport (CDG), was impacted by severe thunderstorms and rain, leading to a prolonged landing. The pilot initiated a controlled landing, but the aircraft suffered a substantial impact, causing damage to the landing gear and fuselage. The incident highlights a critical failure in procedures and data management, ultimately leading to a dangerous situation and a compromised aircraft.An Airbus A330-203 experienced a severe hard landing at Caracas-Sim¢n Bol¡var International Airport (CCS) on Venezuela, resulting in significant damage to the aircraft. The flight, originating from Paris-Charles de Gaulle Airport (CDG), was impacted by severe thunderstorms and rain, leading to a prolonged landing. The pilot initiated a controlled landing, but the aircraft suffered a substantial impact, causing damage to the landing gear and fuselage. The incident highlights a critical failure in procedures and data management, ultimately leading to a dangerous situation and a compromised aircraft.

Description

An Airbus A330-203 sustained substantial damage in a hard landing accident at Caracas-Sim¢n Bol¡var International Airport (CCS), Venezuela. There were no injuries among the 202 passengers and 13 crew members. Flight 470 took off from Paris-Charles de Gaulle Airport (CDG) at 08:55 UTC on a regular service to Caracas, Venezuela. The en route part of the flight was uneventful. Weather at the destination was poor due to the presence of several thunderstorms and rain. The captain was pilot flying during the ILS approach to runway 10 at Caracas. The airplane was aligned with the localizer at 10 NM from the threshold and the glideslope was intercepted at 6 NM. The crew selected a Vapp approach speed of 136 kts and moments later disconnected the autopilot and autothrottle. Passing 1000 feet above aerodrome level the crew was able to observe the runway. Descent rate at the time was -950 feet per minute and the airplane had rolled 3ø to the right at an airspeed of 153 kt (Vapp + 17 kt). Shortly before passing 500 feet the captain had to correct some deviations, causing roll angles reaching 9ø. At 200 feet the airplane was above the glide path and the pilot monitoring reported that the airspeed increased from 138 kt to 153 kt. The airspeed decreased again to below 136 kts with the GPWS warning “Sink Rate!” at 35 feet. The airplane touched down at 2,74 G with a descent rate of -1200 ft/min. Flight 470 taxied to the terminal without any problems. The captain reported the hard landing in the Aircraft Technical Log and reported it to the station manager at Caracas. One Air France technician performed a walk around check in very heavy rain and low light conditions. The Aircraft Condition Monitoring System (ACMS) did not generate an automated ‘hard landing’ report, and no report was received at the company’s Maintenance Control Center (MCC). The Data Management Unit (DMU), part of the ACMS was checked and it was concluded that there was no defect. Consequently, the airplane was released for the return flight to Paris. Upon takeoff from Caracas at 18:30 local time, the crew were not able to raise the undercarriage. Several alarms related to cabin conditioning were triggered and displayed on the ECAM. After burning off fuel the crew landed safely back at Caracas. After parking, significant damage was found on the right hand main landing gear and fuselage structure. Causes: The hard landing is due to the continuation of the landing while the flight path changes should have lead to a go-around. The workload generated by flying without the assistance of A/THR, in degraded weather conditions is a contributing factor. The hard landing caused the implosion of the fixed piston of the damper of the right hand landing gear, which was not detectable on the ground at the stopover. This made it impossible to retract the landing gear during the return flight. The use of inadequate technical notes, the operator into force the day of the event and the lack of issuance of report R15 did not detect the damage caused by the hard landing. This has led to the departure of a commercial flight with a badly damaged aircraft.

Primary Cause

The hard landing was likely a result of a continuation of the landing path, despite a planned go-around. The pilot’s actions, particularly the lack of A/THR assistance in degraded weather conditions, exacerbated the situation. The failure to adequately address the changing flight path and the inadequate documentation surrounding the event significantly contributed to the damage.The hard landing was likely a result of a continuation of the landing path, despite a planned go-around. The pilot’s actions, particularly the lack of A/THR assistance in degraded weather conditions, exacerbated the situation. The failure to adequately address the changing flight path and the inadequate documentation surrounding the event significantly contributed to the damage.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *