Incident Overview

Date: Friday 27 July 2007
Aircraft Type: Airbus A321-231
Owner/operator: British Airways
Registration Number: G-EUXH
Location: London-Heathrow Airport (LHR) – ÿ United Kingdom
Phase of Flight: Standing
Status: Minor, repaired
Casualties: Fatalities: 0 / Occupants: 111
Component Affected: The Boeing 777’s left wing and the Airbus’s fin.The Boeing 777’s left wing and the Airbus’s fin.
Category: Accident
On July 16, 2023, a collision occurred between two Airbus A321 aircraft operated by British Airways, resulting in a significant incident at London Heathrow Terminal 4. The Airbus A321, G-EUXH, landed after an uneventful flight and taxied to Stand 431, while the Boeing 777, G-VIIK, was preparing to depart for Washington, USA from Stand 429. The initial collision was triggered by a failure to activate the electronic Stand Entry Guidance (SEG) system on the Airbus, leading to the commander of the Airbus stopping his aircraft near the parking position. The Boeing 777 crew subsequently requested pushback from Stand 429, which the tug driver approved. During the pushback, the Boeing 777 collided with the Airbus’s fin, causing significant damage. The incident was characterized by a PAN-PAN call from the Airbus crew, followed by a series of further calls and actions by the tug driver, ultimately leading to the aircraft being pulled back onto Stand 429. The incident was primarily attributed to inadequate procedures regarding the Boeing 777 pushback, including delayed stand guidance activation and incomplete risk assessments. The situation highlights a failure to adhere to established operational protocols and potential organizational deficiencies.On July 16, 2023, a collision occurred between two Airbus A321 aircraft operated by British Airways, resulting in a significant incident at London Heathrow Terminal 4. The Airbus A321, G-EUXH, landed after an uneventful flight and taxied to Stand 431, while the Boeing 777, G-VIIK, was preparing to depart for Washington, USA from Stand 429. The initial collision was triggered by a failure to activate the electronic Stand Entry Guidance (SEG) system on the Airbus, leading to the commander of the Airbus stopping his aircraft near the parking position. The Boeing 777 crew subsequently requested pushback from Stand 429, which the tug driver approved. During the pushback, the Boeing 777 collided with the Airbus’s fin, causing significant damage. The incident was characterized by a PAN-PAN call from the Airbus crew, followed by a series of further calls and actions by the tug driver, ultimately leading to the aircraft being pulled back onto Stand 429. The incident was primarily attributed to inadequate procedures regarding the Boeing 777 pushback, including delayed stand guidance activation and incomplete risk assessments. The situation highlights a failure to adhere to established operational protocols and potential organizational deficiencies.

Description

The two aircraft, operated by British Airways, collided on a taxiway adjacent to London Heathrow Terminal 4. The Airbus A321, G-EUXH, had landed after an uneventful flight from Zurich, Switzerland and had taxied to Stand 431 under instructions from the Ground Movements Control 2 (GMC2) controller. As it did so, the crew of the Boeing 777, G-VIIK, were preparing to depart for Washington, USA from Stand 429. Another A321 in the same livery was parked on Stand 432, immediately to the left of G-EUXH. As the Airbus approached its stand, the crew realised that the electronic Stand Entry Guidance (SEG) system was not switched on. This was because the operator’s ground staff responsible for activating it had not yet arrived at the stand. The Airbus commander stopped his aircraft about 50 metres short of the intended parking position; it was aligned with the stand centreline, but with about half the aircraft protruding into the taxiway behind. He made a radio call to GMC2, to advise that the stand guidance was not illuminated, but the frequency was very busy and the call was not acknowledged. Whilst the commander informed the passengers and cabin staff that the aircraft was not yet on stand, the co-pilot attempted to contact his company on discrete frequencies to request that ground crew attend the stand. About a minute after the radio call from the Airbus to GMC2, the crew of the Boeing 777 called GMC2 to request pushback from Stand 429, which the controller approved. During pushback, the Boeing 777’s left wing collided with the Airbus’ fin. The tug driver reported that he had seen the Airbus moments earlier and had applied the vehicle’s brakes, but was too late to prevent the collision. The collision was felt on both aircraft. The Airbus crew made a further call to GMC2, stating that their aircraft had been struck, but it, too, was not acknowledged. They then twice broadcast a PAN-PAN call, which was acknowledged after the second broadcast. The Boeing 777 crew also made a PAN-PAN call. The GMC2 controller took the appropriate actions, and alerted the airport emergency services. The tug was equipped with a radio capable of receiving and making transmissions on the GMC2 frequency, but it was not switched on prior to, or during, the pushback. The Airbus remained stationary after the collision, but the Boeing’s pushback crew immediately pulled the aircraft forward again, back onto Stand 429. The passengers on both aircraft reportedly remained calm and were disembarked via steps. There were no reported injuries. Conclusion: The accident occurred primarily because the Boeing 777 pushback was not conducted in accordance with the aircraft operator’s normal operating procedures and safe practices. Organisational factors which may have contributed to the accident included: the withdrawal of recurrent safety awareness training for ground handling staff, late stand guidance system activation issues, and incomplete risk assessments for towing and pushback operations.

Primary Cause

Failure to adhere to standard operating procedures for Boeing 777 pushback operations, specifically regarding stand guidance activation and risk assessment.Failure to adhere to standard operating procedures for Boeing 777 pushback operations, specifically regarding stand guidance activation and risk assessment.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *