Incident Overview

Date: Tuesday 25 February 1964
Aircraft Type: Douglas DC-8-21
Owner/operator: Eastern Air Lines
Registration Number: N8607
Location: 30,5 km NE off New Orleans International Airport, LA (MSY) – ÿ United States of America
Phase of Flight: En route
Status: Destroyed, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 58 / Occupants: 58
Component Affected: Attitude IndicatorAttitude Indicator
Investigating Agency: CABCAB
Category: Accident
On February 24, 1964, a Douglas DC-8-21 crashed in Lake Pontchartrain after departing from New Orleans International Airport, resulting in the deaths of all five passengers. The aircraft originated from Mexico City and was en route to New York City with intermediate stops. The flight plan indicated a reduced airspeed and a planned flight path involving New Orleans, Atlanta, and Washington. During the climb, the airplane experienced unusual turbulence, including a nose-down pitch, elevator movement to 2 degrees, and a significant wind shear. The pilot responded with ‘OK’ and continued climbing. Subsequently, the airplane struck the surface of Lake Pontchartrain at a dive angle, likely due to pilot induced oscillations (PIO) caused by the attitude indicator’s small size and difficulty in interpretation at night. The degraded stability characteristics caused by turbulence were identified as the probable cause.On February 24, 1964, a Douglas DC-8-21 crashed in Lake Pontchartrain after departing from New Orleans International Airport, resulting in the deaths of all five passengers. The aircraft originated from Mexico City and was en route to New York City with intermediate stops. The flight plan indicated a reduced airspeed and a planned flight path involving New Orleans, Atlanta, and Washington. During the climb, the airplane experienced unusual turbulence, including a nose-down pitch, elevator movement to 2 degrees, and a significant wind shear. The pilot responded with ‘OK’ and continued climbing. Subsequently, the airplane struck the surface of Lake Pontchartrain at a dive angle, likely due to pilot induced oscillations (PIO) caused by the attitude indicator’s small size and difficulty in interpretation at night. The degraded stability characteristics caused by turbulence were identified as the probable cause.

Description

Eastern Air Lines Flight 304, a Douglas DC-8-21, crashed in Lake Pontchartrain, after departure from New Orleans International Airport, LA (MSY). All 58 on board were killed. Flight EA304 originated in Mexico City and had intermediate stops scheduled at New Orleans, Atlanta, and Washington prior to the destination of New York City. The DC-8 arrived at Mexico City at 22:12 on February 24, 1964. The captain of the inbound crew reported that “…the only exception to normality was that the PTC (pitch trim compensator) was inoperative, with a fix scheduled for the next morning at Kennedy Airport.” An IFR flight plan for New Orleans was filed with a reduced airspeed, in accordance with company procedures for dispatch under these conditions. The airplane landed at New Orleans at 00:51. Takeoff from New Orleans was commenced at 01:59. The airplane appeared to climb normally and the crew contacted the departure controller who instructed them to contact New Orleans Center. At 02:03:15 the crew replied, “OK”, this was the last transmission from the flight. During the climb the elevator moved to 2 degrees AND (airplane nose down), which is an abnormal flight condition. Climbing in clouds through 4,000 feet, the DC-8 encountered moderate and probably severe wind shear turbulence. In order to control the airplane under these conditions, the input of the controls probably introduced pilot induced oscillations (PIO) from which the pilot could not recover. Control was lost and the airplane struck the surface of Lake Pontchartrain at a dive angle in excess of 20 degrees. A possible factor was the attitude indicator, which was small with a solid black background and difficult to interpret at night. Also, the pitch indication of the attitude indicator was “geared-down” but not indexed as to degrees, making it more difficult to assess the exact attitude of the airplane. PROBABLE CAUSE: “The Board determines the probable cause of this accident was the degradation of aircraft stability characteristics in turbulence, because of abnormal longitudinal trim component positions.” (CAB report File No. 1-0006)

Primary Cause

Degradation of aircraft stability characteristics in turbulenceDegradation of aircraft stability characteristics in turbulence

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *