Incident Overview

Date: Saturday 17 December 1955
Aircraft Type: Curtiss C-46F Commando
Owner/operator: Riddle Airlines
Registration Number: N9904F
Location: near Hollywood, SC – ÿ United States of America
Phase of Flight: En route
Status: Destroyed, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 2 / Occupants: 2
Component Affected: Rudder elevators, tabs, and control mechanisms.Rudder elevators, tabs, and control mechanisms.
Investigating Agency: CABCAB
Category: Accident
A C-46A aircraft, manufactured and operated by the U.S. Air Force, experienced a catastrophic accident during a scheduled cargo flight from New York to Miami. The aircraft landed at Wilmington, Florida, then departed for Jacksonville, Florida, and subsequently plummeted to the ground near Hollywood, South Carolina. Engine sounds and descending lights were observed, leading to multiple catastrophic crashes. The aircraft was identified as a C-46A and was subsequently converted to C-46E variants.A C-46A aircraft, manufactured and operated by the U.S. Air Force, experienced a catastrophic accident during a scheduled cargo flight from New York to Miami. The aircraft landed at Wilmington, Florida, then departed for Jacksonville, Florida, and subsequently plummeted to the ground near Hollywood, South Carolina. Engine sounds and descending lights were observed, leading to multiple catastrophic crashes. The aircraft was identified as a C-46A and was subsequently converted to C-46E variants.

Description

The aircraft was engaged on a scheduled cargo flight from New York to Miami, Florida, with scheduled stops at Wilmington, North Carolina and Jacksonville, Florida. Flying on a VFR flight plan the aircraft landed at Wilmington at 18:57 and departed again at 19:36, estimating Jacksonville at 21:56. At approximately 20:40, at a point near Hollywood, South Carolina, engines were heard by witnesses and lights were seen descending on an erratic path as the aircraft fell in several pieces to the ground. The aircraft was manufactured for and operated by the U.S. Air Force as a C-46A, and was decommissioned and stored in the Egyptian desert. Subsequently an Italian firm bought the aircraft, and the Curtiss-Wright company authorised this firm to convert C.46A’s to C-46E’s, and provided them with an incomplete set of drawings relative to this conversion, which is identical to that for the C-46F insofar as the tail surfaces arc concerned. Where specified material was not available the nearest available material was used. In every case the strength of the material in the new part exceeded the strength of the material specified. Many of the newly installed parts were heavier than the original parts. A comparison of the rudder elevators, their tabs and their control mechanisms on the accident aircraft with applicable Curtiss-Wright drawings disclosed many nonconformities. PROBABLE CAUSE: “An in-flight structural failure resulting from a violent pitch-down induced by the erratic action of nonconforming elevator tab controls.”

Primary Cause

In-flight structural failure resulting from a violent pitch-down induced by nonconforming elevator tab controls.In-flight structural failure resulting from a violent pitch-down induced by nonconforming elevator tab controls.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *