Incident Overview

Date: Friday 20 October 2000
Aircraft Type: British Aerospace 3201 Jetstream 31
Owner/operator: Atlantic Coast Airlines
Registration Number: N488UE
Location: DULLES, VA – ÿ United States of America
Phase of Flight: Unknown
Status: Substantial
Casualties: Fatalities: 0 / Occupants: 12
Component Affected: The right engine bullgear.The right engine bullgear.
Investigating Agency: NTSBNTSB
Category: Accident
On arrival to the destination airport, an airplane experienced a significant engine failure during descent. The aircraft descended to 5,000 feet, triggering a rapid sequence of events including a loud bang, vibration, and the activation of the fire warning light. A right engine fire occurred, resulting in a significant drop in RPM and the extinguishing of the fire bell. Examination revealed a severe damage to the right engine’s bullgear, including an uncontained separation, multiple fractures, and exceeding wear limits. The gearbox diaphragm suffered significant damage, including a broken bullgear bearing bore, and metallurgical analysis indicated fatigue and multiple fractures. The manufacturer’s inadequate inspection and repair procedures contributed to the failure.On arrival to the destination airport, an airplane experienced a significant engine failure during descent. The aircraft descended to 5,000 feet, triggering a rapid sequence of events including a loud bang, vibration, and the activation of the fire warning light. A right engine fire occurred, resulting in a significant drop in RPM and the extinguishing of the fire bell. Examination revealed a severe damage to the right engine’s bullgear, including an uncontained separation, multiple fractures, and exceeding wear limits. The gearbox diaphragm suffered significant damage, including a broken bullgear bearing bore, and metallurgical analysis indicated fatigue and multiple fractures. The manufacturer’s inadequate inspection and repair procedures contributed to the failure.

Description

The airplane was on the arrival to the destination airport, and was cleared to descend from 8,000 feet to 5,000 feet. A descent was initiated by reducing power on both engines. As the airplane descended through 6,500 feet, the crew heard a loud bang, followed by a vibration, and illumination of the right engine ‘FIRE’ warning light. The right engine RPM dropped to 80 percent and stabilized at that value. The fire bell also sounded. The crew identified the right engine, discharged fire bottle, and the ‘FIRE’ warning light extinguished. The engine was secured and the airplane landed uneventfully at IAD. Examination of the airplane revealed that the right engine bullgear experienced an uncontained separation in flight. A 4 5/8-inch long section of the bullgear rim penetrated the right side of the fuselage and was recovered from the left side interior cabin wall above seat 1A’s seat cushion. Examination of the right engine gearbox revealed that the bull gear was broken into at least six pieces. The gearbox diaphragm’s bull gear bearing bore was measured and found to be over the engine manual’s allowable wear limit. The engine’s maintenance records show that the bull gear was installed new at the last repair, 597 hours and 776 cycles before the event. Metallurgical examination of the bull gear revealed an initial fatigue fracture that originated on the front face of the bull gear outboard of the hub. There were two other fatigue fractures that were on either side of the initial fatigue fracture. The examination also revealed that the bull gear’s web thickness and material hardness conformed to the manufacturer’s design requirements. As a result of this investigation, the FAA was considering an airworthiness directive that would require a recurring sampling of oil to be analyzed for increased levels of metal that could be indicative to bull and high speed pinion gear wear. Probable Cause: The manufacturer’s lack of dimensional inspection and repair requirements for the gearbox forward and aft diaphragm, which caused the bull gear to shift and resulted in an uncontained separation of the bull gear during flight

Primary Cause

Inadequate dimensional inspection and repair requirements for the gearbox forward and aft diaphragm, leading to a shift in the bullgear and subsequent uncontained separation during flight.Inadequate dimensional inspection and repair requirements for the gearbox forward and aft diaphragm, leading to a shift in the bullgear and subsequent uncontained separation during flight.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *