Incident Overview

Date: Sunday 4 July 1965
Aircraft Type: Armstrong Whitworth AW-650 Argosy 222
Owner/operator: British European Airways – BEA
Registration Number: G-ASXL
Location: near Piacenza – ÿ Italy
Phase of Flight: Approach
Status: Destroyed, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 0 / Occupants: 2
Component Affected: Aircraft Navigation System & Pilot ProceduresAircraft Navigation System & Pilot Procedures
Category: Accident
On October 26, 2023, a flight from London-Heathrow to Milan-Linate experienced a significant incident involving a sudden shift in course due to severe thunderstorms. The aircraft initially maintained a normal flight path until approximately 18:38, where it reported its position over Monte Ceneri NDB at FL170. Subsequently, it altered course to avoid a thunderstorm, then descended to 6,000 feet at Linate NDB. However, at 18:55, thunderstorms over Linate prompted a descent to 6,000 feet, with the aircraft heading south. At 19:03, the pilot requested a stop at FL130, and the aircraft then descended to 6,000 feet, following a pattern. The captain reported at FL130 and advised ATC of the situation, but ATC withheld permission until the aircraft reached Linate. At 19:09, the aircraft was cleared to descend to 2,000 feet and then to 6,000 feet, and the pilot reported difficulty receiving the beacon due to interference. The aircraft then entered a level attitude with the undercarriage down and bounced, causing a structural break. No lightning strike was observed, and both pilots agreed the aircraft was operating normally until the last message received.On October 26, 2023, a flight from London-Heathrow to Milan-Linate experienced a significant incident involving a sudden shift in course due to severe thunderstorms. The aircraft initially maintained a normal flight path until approximately 18:38, where it reported its position over Monte Ceneri NDB at FL170. Subsequently, it altered course to avoid a thunderstorm, then descended to 6,000 feet at Linate NDB. However, at 18:55, thunderstorms over Linate prompted a descent to 6,000 feet, with the aircraft heading south. At 19:03, the pilot requested a stop at FL130, and the aircraft then descended to 6,000 feet, following a pattern. The captain reported at FL130 and advised ATC of the situation, but ATC withheld permission until the aircraft reached Linate. At 19:09, the aircraft was cleared to descend to 2,000 feet and then to 6,000 feet, and the pilot reported difficulty receiving the beacon due to interference. The aircraft then entered a level attitude with the undercarriage down and bounced, causing a structural break. No lightning strike was observed, and both pilots agreed the aircraft was operating normally until the last message received.

Description

The flight from London-Heathrow Airport to Milan-Linate Airport was normal until shortly after 18:38 hrs., when the aircraft reported its position over the Monte Ceneri NDB at FL170. A southerly alteration of course was then made to avoid a thunderstorm. At 18:52 hrs., after reporting southwest of Saronno at FL170, the aircraft was cleared to descend to 6,000 ft at the Linate NDB. But at 18:55 hrs the aircraft was still heading south because of thunderstorms over Linate and, when passing FL150, ATC requested that the descent should be stopped at FL130. At 18:58 hrs ATC recleared the aircraft to the Linate NDB at FL130, and then to descend in the Linate bolding pattern to 6,000 ft. At 19:00 hrs the captain reported at FL130 and said be would advice ATC when over the Linate beacon. At about 19:03 hrs he reported his position as over Voghera VOR and requested permission to continue to descend; ATC, however, withheld permission until the aircraft reached Linate. At this time, the Linate weather was reported as: visibility 20 kms, with thunderstorm, clouds 3/8 at 1,500 ft. and 6/8 CuNb at 3,000 ft. At 19:09 hrs the aircraft reported over Linate in thunderstorm conditions and requested permission to descend in the holding pattern; ATC cleared the descent to 6,000 ft. and, two minutes later, to 2,000 ft. At 19:17 hrs. the captain reported that he was having difficulty in receiving the beacon because of interference from the thunderstorm, but was inbound on the ILS. At 19:22 hrs. the aircraft reported at 2,000 ft. inbound, and the pilot added that he would report at the outer marker. This was the last message received from the aircraft, which flew into ground 2,000 ft. amsl, in line with the ILS localiser beam but 33 nm south of the airport. An examination of the wreckage showed that the aircraft had struck the ground in a level attitude with the undercarriage down. It then bounced and bit a sharp rise in the ground about 200 yards further on, causing a complete break-up of the aircraft structure. No evidence was found of any lightning strike and both pilots agreed that there was nothing wrong with the aircraft up to the time of the crash. Probable Cause: The Commission considers that the cause of the accident was a navigational error arising from the following omissions : (1) The failure to take the necessary bearings for a reliable determination of the aircraft’s position in view of the particularly unfavourable weather conditions . (2) The failure to make the fullest possible use of the services of the co-pilot.

Primary Cause

Failure to adequately assess and utilize navigational bearings due to unfavorable weather conditions, specifically the presence of severe thunderstorms.Failure to adequately assess and utilize navigational bearings due to unfavorable weather conditions, specifically the presence of severe thunderstorms.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *