Incident Overview

Date: Sunday 4 March 1962
Aircraft Type: Douglas DC-7C
Owner/operator: Caledonian Airways, lsf Sabena
Registration Number: G-ARUD
Location: 2,5 km E of Douala Airport (DLA) – ÿ Cameroon
Phase of Flight: Initial climb
Status: Destroyed, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 111 / Occupants: 111
Component Affected: Elevator spring-tab mechanism.Elevator spring-tab mechanism.
Category: Accident
On March 1, 1962, a Douglas DC-7, registration G-ARUD, crashed shortly after takeoff from Douala Airport in Cameroon, resulting in the deaths of all 111 passengers. The aircraft, affectionately nicknamed ‘Star of Robbie Burns’, was operating a special charter flight for Trans Africa Air Coach of London, departing Luxembourg (LUX) and destined for Mozambique. The flight, a nighttime takeoff, began at 9350 feet and quickly lost height, encountering significant turbulence and swamp conditions. After a prolonged takeoff, the left wing struck trees approximately 72 feet above aerodrome elevation, causing catastrophic damage. The aircraft subsequently exploded in a tidal swamp, resulting in the loss of all lives. Preliminary investigation suggests a jammed elevator spring-tab mechanism may have been the primary cause of the accident, potentially leading to abnormal elevator control forces during the takeoff. The investigation revealed a history of repeated takeoff runs and a risk of losing height, coupled with an inconsistent rate of climb during flap retraction, which deviated from the SABENA procedure. Furthermore, the presence of a check pilot, potentially distracted, added to the complex circumstances.On March 1, 1962, a Douglas DC-7, registration G-ARUD, crashed shortly after takeoff from Douala Airport in Cameroon, resulting in the deaths of all 111 passengers. The aircraft, affectionately nicknamed ‘Star of Robbie Burns’, was operating a special charter flight for Trans Africa Air Coach of London, departing Luxembourg (LUX) and destined for Mozambique. The flight, a nighttime takeoff, began at 9350 feet and quickly lost height, encountering significant turbulence and swamp conditions. After a prolonged takeoff, the left wing struck trees approximately 72 feet above aerodrome elevation, causing catastrophic damage. The aircraft subsequently exploded in a tidal swamp, resulting in the loss of all lives. Preliminary investigation suggests a jammed elevator spring-tab mechanism may have been the primary cause of the accident, potentially leading to abnormal elevator control forces during the takeoff. The investigation revealed a history of repeated takeoff runs and a risk of losing height, coupled with an inconsistent rate of climb during flap retraction, which deviated from the SABENA procedure. Furthermore, the presence of a check pilot, potentially distracted, added to the complex circumstances.

Description

Caledonian Airways flight 153, a Douglas DC-7, crashed shortly after takeoff from Douala Airport, Cameroon, killing all 111 occupants. The heavily-laden DC-7 was making a night takeoff from Douala runway 12 in conditions of high ambient temperature and humidity. After a long takeoff from the 9350 feet long runway, it gained little height. Some 2300yds from the runway end, 500yds left of the extended centreline, the left wing struck trees 72 feet above aerodrome elevation. The DC-7, named “Star of Robbie Burns”, crashed into a tidal swamp and exploded on impact. The flight, a special charter flight on behalf of Trans Africa Air Coach of London, had departed Luxembourg (LUX) on March 1, 1962, arriving in Louren‡o Marques (now Maputo), Mozambique on March 2.The flight left again on March 4, bound for Douala (DLA), Cameroon, Lisbon (LIS), Portugal and Luxembourg. PROBABLE CAUSE: “In spite of the very numerous expert examinations and all the tests on the ground and in flight which the Commission of Inquiry has carried out or caused to be carried out, the state of the wreckage and its position in an inundated forest area have prevented the Commission from determining with absolute certainty the cause of the accident to DC-7C G-ARUD. The commission considers, however, that there is evidence to show that an elevator spring-tab mechanism may have jammed before impact. This jamming would have resulted in abnormal elevator control forces during the takeoff. Flight tests have shown this to be consistent with a prolonged takeoff run and a risk of losing height during flap retraction. Furthermore, the following features, all adverse, may have aggravated the circumstances in which the accident occurred: – the implementation of a procedure for gaining speed which was conducive to the aircraft being flown at a low altitude – the fact that a positive rate of climb was not maintained at the time of flap retraction which, in the SABENA procedure applied by Caledonian Airways, is not subject to any altitude limitation other than that of obstacle clearance – the presence in the co-pilot’s seat of a check pilot whose attention may have been attracted more by the actions of the first pilot than by the indications on his own instrument panel. The Commission had been unable to eliminate an instrument failure as a possible cause of the accident, as the instruments were not recovered or were too seriously damaged to allow of any valid expert examination.”

Primary Cause

Probable cause: ‘In spite of the very numerous expert examinations and all the tests on the ground and in flight which the Commission of Inquiry has carried out or caused to be carried out, the state of the wreckage and its position in an inundated forest area have prevented the Commission from determining with absolute certainty the cause of the accident to DC-7C G-ARUD.’Probable cause: ‘In spite of the very numerous expert examinations and all the tests on the ground and in flight which the Commission of Inquiry has carried out or caused to be carried out, the state of the wreckage and its position in an inundated forest area have prevented the Commission from determining with absolute certainty the cause of the accident to DC-7C G-ARUD.’

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *