Incident Overview

Date: Saturday 18 February 1961
Aircraft Type: Douglas DC-7CF
Owner/operator: Pan American World Airways (Pan Am)
Registration Number: N745PA
Location: Stuttgart-Echterdingen Airport (STR) – ÿ Germany
Phase of Flight: Approach
Status: Destroyed, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 0 / Occupants: 3
Component Affected: Approach Lights, ILS Glide Slope, UndercarriageApproach Lights, ILS Glide Slope, Undercarriage
Category: Accident
A PanAm DC-7 aircraft experienced a severe accident during a freight flight from Frankfurt to Stuttgart. Due to deteriorating weather conditions ? fog with low surface and vertical visibility ? the approach was initiated with an unreliable ILS glide slope. The pilot attempted to establish minima, but the aircraft was forced to abort the approach when these minima were reached. A sudden impact with a 10-foot high mound of earth resulted in significant damage, including damage to the undercarriage and the third engine. The flight crew successfully regained control and diverted to Nrnberg airport for an emergency belly landing.A PanAm DC-7 aircraft experienced a severe accident during a freight flight from Frankfurt to Stuttgart. Due to deteriorating weather conditions ? fog with low surface and vertical visibility ? the approach was initiated with an unreliable ILS glide slope. The pilot attempted to establish minima, but the aircraft was forced to abort the approach when these minima were reached. A sudden impact with a 10-foot high mound of earth resulted in significant damage, including damage to the undercarriage and the third engine. The flight crew successfully regained control and diverted to Nrnberg airport for an emergency belly landing.

Description

The PanAm DC-7 operated on a freight flight from Frankfurt to Stuttgart; weather forecasted for Stuttgart was poor: 100 m surface and vertical visibility in fog. NOTAMs were current, reporting inoperative 1, 3, 4, and 5 crossbars of the approach lights and an unreliable ILS glide slope because of airport construction works. An ILS approach attempted (by the first officer as pilot-flying) to see in minima for the aircraft (ceiling 200 m, 1/2 mile visibility) existed. When minima were reached, the approach was discontinued. The plane then suddenly hit a 10-foot high mound of earth located 66 feet short of the runway threshold and 149 feet north of the north edge of the runway. Impact tore off the undercarriage and the no. 3 engine. Control was maintained and the flight crew managed to climb away and divert to Nrnberg airport for an emergency belly landing on a foamed runway. PROBABLE CAUSE: “(1) Improperly executed instrument approach during which the aircraft was permitted to descend below obstructing terrain before initiating a missed approach. (2) Inadequate supervision by the captain.”

Primary Cause

Improperly executed instrument approach during which the aircraft was permitted to descend below obstructing terrain before initiating a missed approach.Improperly executed instrument approach during which the aircraft was permitted to descend below obstructing terrain before initiating a missed approach.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *