Incident Overview

Date: Thursday 27 February 1958
Aircraft Type: Bristol 170 Freighter 21E
Owner/operator: Manx Airlines
Registration Number: G-AICS
Location: Winter Hill – ÿ United Kingdom
Phase of Flight: En route
Status: Destroyed, written off
Casualties: Fatalities: 35 / Occupants: 42
Component Affected: Radio CompassRadio Compass
Category: Accident
A Manx Airlines Bristol 170 aircraft carrying 35 passengers and 7 crew members crashed on Winter Hill, U.K., resulting in a fatal accident. The aircraft was operating a flight from the Isle of Man to Manchester, UK, and prior to takeoff, the captain adjusted the altitude to avoid a delay. The captain mistakenly set the radio compass to Oldham Beacon instead of Wigan Beacon, leading to a navigational error. The radio compass signal was incorrectly interpreted as Wigan Beacon, causing the aircraft to deviate from its intended course. The aircraft then crashed on the northeast slope of Winter Hill, approximately 1460 feet above ground level. The incident was likely caused by a failure to properly tune the radio compass to the correct beacon, resulting in a misinterpretation of the signal.A Manx Airlines Bristol 170 aircraft carrying 35 passengers and 7 crew members crashed on Winter Hill, U.K., resulting in a fatal accident. The aircraft was operating a flight from the Isle of Man to Manchester, UK, and prior to takeoff, the captain adjusted the altitude to avoid a delay. The captain mistakenly set the radio compass to Oldham Beacon instead of Wigan Beacon, leading to a navigational error. The radio compass signal was incorrectly interpreted as Wigan Beacon, causing the aircraft to deviate from its intended course. The aircraft then crashed on the northeast slope of Winter Hill, approximately 1460 feet above ground level. The incident was likely caused by a failure to properly tune the radio compass to the correct beacon, resulting in a misinterpretation of the signal.

Description

A Manx Airlines Bristol 170 impacted Winter Hill, U.K.,killing 35 occupants; 7 survived the accident. The Bristol 170 aircraft was being operated by Manx Airlines on a flight from the Isle of Man to Manchester, United Kingdom. Prior to takeoff, in order to avoid delay, a clearance to fly at 1500 ft was offered and accepted. In the light of past experience the captain anticipated that he would be cleared to a higher altitude on crossing the English coast. Between Ronaldsway and the reporting point at Squire’s Gate the flight was made below cloud practically all the way. Visibility was reasonably good. The captain went below to talk to the passengers for approximately a five minute period. During his absence the first officer set the radio compass on what he thought was Wigan Beacon, but, was in fact Oldham Beacon. The Oldham Beacon is a more powerful NDB with a morse recognition signal ‘MYL’. Wigan NDB has a recognition signal ‘MYK’. On his return to the cockpit the captain took over the piloting of the aircraft. He assumed that the radio compass was tuned in to Wigan. Just prior to 09:38 hours the aircraft reported to Preston Control “abeam Blackpool at this time estimating Wigan at 43”. At 09:39 the Preston controller radioed: “You are cleared to Wigan 1500 feet remaining contact. Call Manchester Zone for onward clearance.” At 09:44, one minute after it would have been over the Wigan NDB, the flight was in cloud and out of contact with the ground. Manchester Control the radioed, “Charlie Sierra will you make a right turn immediately on to a heading of two five zero. I have a faint paint on radar which indicates you’re going over towards the hills.” Shortly thereafter in the course of making the right turn as ordered, the aircraft crashed on the northeast slope of Winter Hill, at a height of approximately 1460 ft. PROBABLE CAUSE: “The error of the first officer in tuning the radio compass on Oldham Beacon instead of on Wigan Beacon. A contributory cause was the failure of the captain to check that the radio compass was tuned on the correct beacon.”

Primary Cause

Incorrect radio compass tuning to Oldham Beacon instead of Wigan Beacon.Incorrect radio compass tuning to Oldham Beacon instead of Wigan Beacon.

Share on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *